I have a soft spot for narrative-driven, choice-heavy games like these: life is strangedispatch, until dawnand Dark Pictures AnthologySo no one will be surprised Directive 8020 is high on my list of games to play in May 2026. Before that, my wife and I sat down and played each game ahead of each new release. Of course, the best way to play them overall is in release order. These include Man of Medan, Little Hope, House of Ashes, and The Devil in Me..
In other words, what the player experiences that way is an acceptable beginning, a high point in the middle, and a weak (although that's not the definition of “weak”) end. This game refers to season 1. Dark Pictures AnthologyAnd it will be interesting to see what happens after Season 2 releases. Directive 8020. Otherwise, sitting down and marathoning these four games is a great way to pass the time ahead of Directive 8020. In the end, playing each game once only takes about 6-7 hours. Directive 8020 It releases on May 12th, so this is your reminder to start your marathon soon. If time permits, I would also like to recommend it. until dawn And the quarry. This ranking does not include the Dark Pictures: Switchback VR spinoff game.
Since there are only four games, we decided to limit it to one game per tier.
S-Tier: House of Ashes
house of ashes You explore a Sumerian temple filled with vampires, which are wild beasts and not the Dracula or shiny kind. One of the best creature-centric horror games in gaming, not just Supermassive. until dawn and quarry appropriate dark picture Branding. Overall, this piece has a clearer identity than its predecessors, which helps build tension the entire time, while avoiding (for the most part) the ambiguity that sometimes weakened it in previous entries.
Directive 8020 promotes fear of space and the body [PREVIEW]
After a brief presentation at Gamescom, it became clear that waiting for Directive 8020 would be worth it. Especially for space/body horror fans.
house of ashes'The characters all benefit from strong, sharp writing. Especially the interpersonal conflict between the survivors (since they are soldiers on opposing sides). Gameplay-wise, it feels polished, the pace is strong, the use of action is closely tied to horror, and character survival feels at a premium.
What is that weapon?
Check out the silhouette before time runs out.
start
Check out the silhouette before time runs out.
Easy (7.5 seconds) Medium (5.0 seconds) Hard (2.5 seconds) Eternal Death (2.5 seconds)
Tier A: Little Hope
little hope Definitely gets points for the timeline and setting. house of ashes. As with all these games, the player takes on the role of a few characters in the game as well. little hope They become trapped in an abandoned New England town in Massachusetts. The story weaves together three events: the witch trials of 1692, a family tragedy in the 1970s, and modern times. In all three, themes of guilt, trauma, and psychotic breakdown are addressed, making full use of historical parallels and recurring character archetypes.
Dark Pictures: Little Hope Review
The Dark Pictures: Little Hope's characters and story take a step back from Man of Medan, but there's still plenty to enjoy.
little hopeThe ending is understandably divisive. While conveying the core theme (and building on the player's decisions), some ultimately argue that every choice undermines the player's agency and 'little hope'In retrospect, his choices make less sense. It's an understandable criticism, although it's well explained in-game. Nonetheless, the journey itself is compelling enough to warrant a high ranking, especially for players who value story over mechanical depth.
B Tier: Man of Medan
Always respect OG, Man of Medan He deserves credit for establishing the core formula. The Dark Pictures Anthology. The setting aboard the ghost ship has a lot of potential and delivers some truly tense moments, at least once you get into play. 'Man of Medan'Gameplay modes encourage shared experiences (so it's always best to play with a friend or partner). That said, the game suffers from uneven pacing, with the narrative building slowly and then quickly losing momentum. similar little hopeThere are multiple timelines for this, but in a less attractive way. And the characters Man of Medan It's solid, if almost forgettable.
The Dark Pictures: Man of Medan review
The Dark Pictures: Man of Medan may not be as polished as Until Dawn, but it's still an effective horror game experience with a great story.
Don't misunderstand. Man of Medan It lays some very important groundwork, but it feels more like a proof of concept than a fully realized Dark Pictures game. But this is a B-Tier, not something like D or F-Tier. Despite its shortcomings, Man of Medan It's an incredibly fun, narrative-driven game.
Click or tap the game that matches your category.
start
C-Tier: The devil inside me
the devil inside me It deserves recognition for the efforts made to improve it. dark picture Especially considering the annual flow, the formula and its successes (and debatable failures) bode well for those who: Directive 8020 It does the same thing with added development time. The premise of a murder hotel inspired by real-life serial killer HH Holmes is incredibly inspired and gives it a completely different flavor of horror than previous titles, but that inspiration isn't consistently applied to the trap designs and set pieces. New mechanics like inventory management and exploration-focused gameplay make sense as additions, but they can also feel underdeveloped at times.
The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil in Me Review
Despite some shortcomings and inconsistencies, The Dark Pictures: Devil in Me concludes the anthology's first season strongly.
And the character work is okay, dark picture Set expectations higher than expected the devil inside me The game spends too much time moving around the characters. the devil inside meopening. That is, despite defects (e.g. Man of Medan), the devil inside me Worth every play.
Dark Pictures Season 2 begins on May 12 with Directive 8020.
Directive 8020 It represents the evolution of the franchise. Four years have passed since it was finally released. the devil inside meAll four games in 'Season 1' are the last games in the franchise to be released within four years. In this game, players take control of five playable protagonists in the new horror genre of Cosmic Horror. The main character is astronaut Brianna Young, played by actress Lashana Lynch, who must survive the shape-shifting aliens among her crew when their spaceship lands on the planet Tau Ceti f. It's basically among usHowever, it is horror-centric and would be a great way to spend the night on May 12th.
As GameRant wrote in the preview: Directive 8020“The setting is strong, and there's a lot of potential for uncertainty as the story continues to build, especially once it becomes clear that the creators don't really understand what they're dealing with. We need more time with the characters to really care about the outcome, but the direction feels more focused than we've seen from Supermassive in the past. If the overall game can maintain that tension while giving room to develop ideas, it could end up being one of the studio's more complete experiences.”
- released
-
May 12, 2026
- ESRB
-
Ages 17+ / Intense violence, blood and gore, strong language, in-game purchases, user interaction
