by FromSoftware's name became synonymous with dark fantasy, and the studio didn't need a specific kind of setting to bring its ideas to life in a big way. The real appeal has always been how completely committed it is to the danger, mystery, and history of the world. That's why recent rumors about a pirate-themed FromSoftware game are easy to get behind, even though reports of its existence still need to be ignored. The developer has already confirmed that they have multiple projects in development across a variety of genres, and a pirate Soulslike would be one of the most exciting possibilities if it became a reality.
According to a recent leak, the rumored title of the game is: Cerulean Onslaught Although nothing has been officially confirmed, we could see FromSoftware diving into a pirate-inspired action RPG complete with sails, islands, and ships that act as hubs. Still, the idea is too good to ignore. Pirates, cursed treasures, ghost ships, drowned ruins, sea monsters, and lost civilizations already sound like a part of the FromSoftware universe, and if these rumors are true, it could be a 10/10 dream come true.
16 Best Soulslike Games Easier Than Dark Souls
Are you tired of constantly dying? Finding the best Soulslike games of 2026 has never been easier than Dark Souls, including new releases like Nioh 3.
Corsair is better suited to software than it needs to be.
Typically, pirates are treated first as adventure fantasy. This generally means open seas, buried treasure, ship battles, taverns, rival crews, and in some versions free players must head out into the open seas and go where the wind takes them. This version of the genre can certainly be exciting, but it's not the only way to approach pirates. The darkest pirate stories are about greed, isolation, violence, superstition, betrayal, and men chasing treasure to places it could never find. That version of the pirated version already sounds much closer to the FromSoftware game.
Rearranges covers into correct US release order.
start
Rearranges covers into correct US release order.
Easy (5)Medium (7)Difficult (10)
But that's also why rumors are easy to spot even before we know the specific details that have been leaked. FromSoftware doesn't need to force pirates into the formula because there's already enough danger and mythology inherent in pirate fantasy. All the studio had to do was strip away the usual romanticism that came with it and leave behind something weirder and decidedly harsher. To be honest, I think the dark side of pirates is for FromSoftware and for FromSoftware. Additionally, the industry has already seen a lot of pirated games doing essentially the same thing, and if FromSoftware is known for doing something, they're doing something different.
Spirit-loving pirates can avoid the genre's biggest pitfalls.
It's true that pirate games tend to live and die by how much freedom they promise, and that makes sense. The idea of open seas, ship battles, hidden treasures, rival sailors, hidden islands, and total freedom is immediately exciting. But it also creates expectations that are nearly impossible to fully satisfy. Once the novelty of sailing wears off, pirate games need to give players more than just miles to cross and supplies to manage. The world must continue to feel worth investigating.
To be honest, I think the dark side of pirates is for FromSoftware and for FromSoftware.
This is where FromSoftware could have a real advantage with this rumor, assuming there is any truth to it. The studio has always been good at making exploration suspenseful, as players rarely have a full sense of the situation they're entering. The pirate setting gives the instinct a natural new form, as the genre is already built around uncertainty. Every voyage contains the potential for reward, risk, betrayal, or something better left undiscovered.
This is important because Soulslike pirates can lose their identity if they follow the genre's typical checklist too closely. Ship customization, naval combat, crew management, treasure hunting, etc. can all have a place, but the most powerful version of this idea is one that allows these features to communicate to the world rather than being the entire point. This rumored dream version is a dangerous, strange, and tightly designed action RPG that gives pirate fantasy a harsher twist on FromSoftware's new mythology.
Ship hub could be the best idea in the game
But if there's one leaked detail that seems particularly promising, it's the idea of the player's ship acting as a hub. In Pirate Soullike, ships must be more than just a place for players to navigate between dangerous areas. That should be the clearest indication of the journey itself, carrying crew, wounds, rewards, and even the consequences of everything the player brings with them in the world.
This rumored dream version is a dangerous, strange, and tightly designed action RPG that gives pirate fantasy a harsher twist on FromSoftware's new mythology.
This can make your ship one of the most important parts of the entire game. FromSoftware's hubs are often memorable because they change in small but meaningful ways as players move further into the unknown. The pirate ship makes these changes easier to spot. New faces may appear on board, strange discoveries may change the space, and parts of the ship may open over time. Even the simple act of returning from a voyage can become part of the core gameplay loop.
The idea becomes more interesting as the ship becomes unstable over time. Classic FromSoftware hubs tend to provide a sense of security without feeling completely safe, and the pirate ship would be a great place to explore that idea further. The more players rely on it, the more it may start to reflect the darker parts of their journey. In the case of Pirate Soulslike, this can turn a ship into something charming enough to feel like home and strange enough to make players question what they've brought with them so far.
Of course, the ship is only one part of the playing field, but it nonetheless shows why this idea has so much potential. FromSoftware's Pirate Soulslike can pull off a lot more than ships, swords, and treasure maps. The dark side of piracy already provides studios with material on which to thrive. It's greed that leads people too far, superstitions that turn into reality, and exploration that feels dangerous because every discovery comes with a price. Cerulean Onslaught It's still just a rumor, but if FromSoftware is actually making a game based on that kind of fantasy, it's easy to see why this idea already sounds like a 10/10 dream come true.
