8 characters that Oda should have killed off

This article contains spoilers. one piece.

Regarding character deaths, Eiichiro Oda one piece They rarely deliver. Instead of having characters collapse and remain dead, Oda has a habit of faking his characters' deaths. It doesn't matter how permanent their departure seems or how heartbreaking their sacrifice is. one piece It never fails to find shocking ways to undo it.

relevant

One Piece: 7 Characters Saved by the Plot

One Piece is a great story, but despite this, some characters, like Luffy, are often saved for the sole purpose of the plot.

As a result, one piece There are some truly emotional moments and heroic scenes that ultimately failed to impact fans as the character's survival was ensured. The story would have been better Did Eiichiro Oda kill off these characters? one piece Instead of allowing them to live to see another light.

butler mary

Clarador should have killed Mary.

Kaya's butler from Syrup Village named Mary survives a fatal attack by Clarador, known as Captain Kuro, a member of the Black Cat Pirates. It was a miracle that Merry survived, but if she had met her permanent death, the danger facing Usopp, Kaya, and the Straw Hat Pirates would have been even greater.

Merry is the designer of the Straw Hat Pirates' first ship, but killing him permanently would have added more meaning to the Going Merry and all of Luffy's crew's voyages. Nonetheless, the first season of the One Piece live-action adaptation appears to have addressed this missed opportunity by actually sending Merry away, rather than allowing her to survive Kuro's attack, as Oda wrote.

hogbag

One Piece character Oda should have killed Hogback. — One Piece character Oda should have been killed

Hogback should have been killed by Oars.

Since the mad doctor in the Thriller Bark arc successfully avoided death, not even a stomp of the giant can finish off Hogback, much to fans' surprise. Everyone thought Hogback was done for once, but lo and behold, he reappears with Moria and Absalom on an escape boat.

Hogback's second chance at life one piece It often defies logic and there is no true final defeat in the series. His death, which seemed fatal to Oars' hand or foot, was shrugged off, and he was allowed to return with his body heavily bandaged. Hogback is unfazed by his proximity to death and quickly returns to his sinister hobby of turning corpses into zombies as if nothing had happened.

pell

One Piece character Oda should have killed Fel. — One Piece character Oda should have been killed

Pell should have died in the bombing.

For many fans, Fel is the first character that comes to mind when asked which of Eiichiro Oda's characters actually should have died. one piece. After all, his final moments in the Alabasta arc were so overflowing with heroism that his ultimate sacrifice for the kingdom could immediately touch anyone's heart.

Fel soared into the skies of Aluvana carrying a giant bomb planted by Lord Crocodile, determined to save the city at the cost of his life. The bomb exploded as Crocodile had planned, but Pell was able to escape the blast site with treatable injuries.

Pell's survival robs the final scene of Alubarna's chaos of its full emotional power, turning what should have been an unforgettable moment into a close call.

pecoms

Oda, the One Piece character, should have killed Pekoms. — One Piece character Oda should have been killed

Pekoms had to be killed by Capone Bege.

There's an inside joke between one piece Fans talk about characters whose names start with P. They say these characters have 'the will of P'. Because no matter how difficult a situation is, you can somehow survive. Lion Mink avoids death several times while dealing with Capone Bege, so Pekoms is no exception.

Bege not only shot Pekoms in the back, but also asked his men to feed the lion mink in shark-infested waters to keep it alive. Because of this, many fans believe that Pekoms is protected by pubic armor, but his Devil Fruit ability to transform into a full-fledged turtle or turtle-mink hybrid may actually explain his miraculous survival.

Click or tap the game that matches your category.

Pagaya

Pagaya should have been killed by Enel's lightning.

Surviving Enel's Judgment is an impressive feat for the Skypiean, as the lightning that struck Pagaya was devastating in every way. The attack hit Pagaya directly and there seemed to be no chance of him returning, but Eiichiro Oda spared him like many other characters on this list without a proper explanation.

Pagaya should have died in that scene to create a truly heartbreaking moment that would have fostered Conis' character growth. Unfortunately, his survival is another missed opportunity, turning what could have been a powerful motivation for character growth into a chaotic scene that feels safe. In the end, Pagaya even joined in the celebrations following Henel's defeat as if his fatal injury had never existed.

Kumadori

Kumadori should have been killed by the monster Point Chopper.

CP9 Agent Kumadori is a man as strong as steel, able to withstand the brutal attacks of the monster Point Chopper, which takes down most enemies. Not only did the monster Point Chopper mercilessly slam him to the ground, but the reindeer's ultimate transformation threw him onto the court as if he were a smashed bug.

While being tortured, Kumadori remained motionless like a corpse and could not lift a finger against the monster Point Chopper. If Kumadori had died during the Enies Lobby arc, it would have created a shocking and powerful moment for the Straw Hats, especially Chopper, who was just starting to show off his fighting powers.

Kinemon

Kinemon had to be killed by Kaido.

Pell would be proud of Kin'emon after surviving Kaido's kanabo and katana attacks while also protecting Momonosuke during the Wano arc, which was one of the deadliest story arcs. one piece. Most fans thought Kinemon was finished after his fatal encounter with Kaido, but Oda's foolish excuse was enough to later justify his survival.

Kinemon's survival was a relief, but his miraculous escape quickly eased Wano's nerves. Watching Episode 1035 of One Piece will never be the same again. Because the character avoided a critical hit, a lot of the impact of that moment was lost. It was one of the biggest disappointments of the Wano Arc, and that frustration will certainly persist as long as Kin'emon lives.

Jaguar D. Saul

Oda, the One Piece character, should have killed Jaguar Saul. — One Piece character Oda should have been killed

Saul should have died at Ohara.

The revelation that Jaguar D. Saul was alive all along is one of the most shocking twists in Eiichiro Oda's One Piece. Saul, a character thought to have disappeared for years, surprisingly reappears in Elbaf, working as a history teacher.

It's nice that Robin has Saul again after Aokiji's attack and the horror of O'Hara's Buster Call, but his survival lessens the gravity of Robin's shocking backstory. For many fans, this is the final straw as they feel that Saul's death in One Piece can no longer be trusted with his survival. What's worse is that Saul is back. one piece We did not receive proper build-up from Oda, resulting in fruitless returns.

release date: October 20, 1999
network: Fuji TV
move: Hiroaki Miyamoto, Konosuke Uda, Junji Shimizu, Satoshi Ito, Munehisa Sakai, Katsumi Tokoro, Yutaka Nakajima, Yoshihiro Ueda, Kenichi Takeshita, Yoko Ikeda, Ryota Nakamura, Hiroyuki Kakudo, Takahiro Imamura, Toshihiro Maeya, Yuji Endo, Nozomu Shishido, Hidehiko Kadota, Sumio Watanabe, Harume Kosaka, Yasuhiro Tanabe, Yukihiko Nakao, Keisuke Onishi, Junichi Fujise, Hiroyuki Sato
author: Jin Tanaka, Akiko Inoue, Junki Takegami, Shinzo Fujita, Shoji Yonemura, Yoshiyuki Suga, Atsuhiro Tomioka, Hirohiko Uesaka, Michiru Shimada, Isao Murayama, Takuya Masumoto, Yoichi Takahashi, Momoka Toyoda.

Mayumi Tanaka

Monkey D. Luffy (voice)
Kazuya Nakai

Roronoa Zoro (voice)